Overview

Welcome

News & Events

Leadership

Elections

Writing Competition

Fellowship Program

Newsletter

Previous Editions

Division Business

Amicus Curiae

Resources

Continuing Legal Education (CLE)

Roster

Contact Us

Join


Search Planning.org

My APA

Error...

There was an Error Processing Your Request...

This page is unavailable due to a system error; the error has been logged and the appropriate persons notified. We apologize for the inconvenience and ask you to try again later. If the problem persists, please contact WebsiteFeedback@Planning.org.

Error occurred: 6:25:17 AM at /planningandlaw/writingcompetition.htm.

Smith Babcock Williams Writing Competition

Deadline for entries: June 9, 2008

Entries are now being accepted for the 2008 competition. Click here to download the guidelines.


About the Competition

The Planning & Law Division of the American Planning Association announces its Twenty-fifth Annual Smith-Babcock-Williams Student Writing Competition. The Competition, which honors the memory of three leading figures in American city planning law — R. Marlin Smith, Richard Babcock, and Norman Williams — is open to law students and planning students, writing on a question of significance in planning, planning law, land use law, local government law or environmental law.

The winning entry will be awarded a prize of $2,500 and will be submitted for publication in The Urban Lawyer, the law journal of the American Bar Association's Section of State & Local Government Law. In addition to the first prize, the Competition will offer a second place prize of $1,000 and up to two Honorable Mentions of $250. The deadline for submission of entries is June 9, 2008 and the winners will be announced by September 15, 2008. Please refer to the official rules for further details.


2007 Winners

The entry awarded first prize in the 2007 was "Constructing the Special Theater Subdistrict: Culture, Politics, and Economics in the Creation of Transferable Development Rights," submitted by Michael Kruse, a 2007 graduate of New York University School of Law. Mr. Kruse's entry was submitted for publication in The Urban Lawyer.

The entry awarded second prize in the 2007 competition was "Broadened Notions of Historic Preservation and the Role of Neighborhood Conservation Districts," submitted by Adam Lovelady, who will graduate from the University of Virginia School of Law in 2008.

Honorable Mention awards were given to "Powerful Tool or Insurmountable Obstacle: The Relationship Between Eminent Domain and the Affordable Housing Crisis," submitted by Emily Stubbs, who will graduate from J. Reuben Clark Law School at Brigham Young University in 2008 and "Tax Incentives for Historic Preservation Easement Donations: A Review of New Reforms Under the Pension Protection Act of 2006," submitted by Melaina Jobs, who will graduate from the University of Connecticut School of Law in 2008.


2006 Winners

First Prize 2006

"Productive Preservation and the Reinvention of Industrial America"
Jonathan H. Flynn, Georgetown University Law Center
This entry has been submitted for publication in The Urban Lawyer.

Second Prize 2006

"Balancing Community Needs and Individual Property Rights Post-Kelo: A State Legislature's Guide to Drafting Urban Planning-Based Statutes"
Rachel D. Jaffe, 2006 graduate of Temple University Beasley School of Law

Honorable Mentions 2006

"Unplanned Change, Challenging Tradition in Land Use Controls: The Case of New Haven's Planned Development District"
Shruti Ravikumar, Yale Law School

"The Legalities of Stream Interventions: Accretive Changes to New York State's Riparian Doctrine Ahead?"
Danielle Sibener Pensley, Cornell Law School


2005 Winners

First Prize 2005

"Urban Height Restrictions Without Law: A Philadelphia Story"
Benjamin M. Gerber, Harvard Law School

Honorable Mention

"Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions ... on Free Speech? First Amendment Rights in Common-Interest Communities"
Adrienne Iwamoto Suarez, William S. Richardson School of Law at the University of Hawaii

"Subordinate or Fundamental Rights in Property? Special Benefits and Givings Recapture in Determining Just Compensation"
Larissa N. Schwartz, William S. Richardson School of Law at the University of Hawaii

2004 Winners

First Prize 2004

"Cutting Through the Clause: The Land Use Planning Impacts of Moving 'Partial Takings' from Political Theory to Legal Reality"
George Homsy, Cornell University, Department of City & Regional Planning

Honorable Mention

"Planning for Biodiversity Protection: Policy Lessons from Regional Planning for Affordable Housing"
Rebecca C. Retzlaff, Urban Planning and Policy Program, University of Illinois at Chicago

"Narrowing the Public Use Doctrine: State Courts Take Back the Takings Clause"
Malia Emerson Schreck, William S. Richardson School of Law, University of Hawaii at Manoa


2003 Winners

First Prize 2003

"Preservation of Historic Properties' Environs: American & French Approaches"
Francois Quintard-Morenas, Georgetown University Law Center, LL.M. (2003)

Honorable Mention

"Inner-Ring Suburbs and 'Economic Blight': Should Economic Rationales Alone be Enough to Justify Use of Eminent Domain as a Means of Urban Redevelopment?"
Michael Graham, Cleveland State University, JD/MUPDD (2004)

"Effective Land Use Policy and Legislation in China: The Key to the Future of Urban Development of the World's Most Populous Nation"
Ezekiel A. Kaufman, Washington University School of Law, JD (2003)